2024 RLLR 145
Citation: 2024 RLLR 145
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: February 21, 2024
Panel: Ramona Muljar
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Leo Chan
Country: Russia
RPD Number: VC3-05035
Associated RPD Number(s): VC2-10011
ATIP Number: A-2025-00724
ATIP Pages: N/A
DECISION
[1] MEMBER: This is the decision of the Refugee Protection Division in the claims by XXXX XXXX and XXXX XXXX, who are both citizens of Russia and who have filed claims for protection under sections 96 and 97 of the Immigration Refugee Protection Act of Canada. In coming to my decision, I considered the testimony that we heard here today, the evidence that you, the claimant, submitted prior to the hearing, as well as the relevant and most recent country condition information available to me. As well, in coming to my decision, I did also consider and apply the Chairperson’s Guideline 9 on Proceedings Before the IRB Involving Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity and Expression, And Sex Characteristics, or SOGIESC for short. For example, I applied this Guideline’s sections 8.5.1, whereby having to conceal one’s sexual orientation to avoid harm is in itself persecutory.
DETERMINATION
[2] I determined that you both meet the definition of a Convention refugee pursuant to section 96 of the Act, as you both have a well-founded fear of persecution in your home country based on a Convention ground. My reasons follow.
ALLEGATIONS
[3] The allegations were set out in detail in your family-based written Basis of Claim form, so I will just summarize those allegations here briefly.
[4] You both identify as individuals with diverse SOGIESC. Ms. XXXX, the principal claimant, is a transgender woman, and the associate claimant is a bisexual man. You both have been living together since around 2012. You testified that life was never easy for either of you, and you were both often subjected to discrimination and harassment. In 2015, the principal claimant participated in a XXXX XXXX and her transgender background was revealed. After this, you both were subjected to multiple violent attacks by unknown individuals, and the most violent ones having occurred in 2013, 2015, 2016 and 2022. When you tried to get help from the police, they were not interested in helping you. Things kept escalating and getting worse until you were ultimately able to leave Russia in 2022. You both fear physical harm, and even death, in Russia due to your SOGIESC background, especially taking into account the recent anti-LGBTQ sentiment fueled by President Putin in Russia.
Identity
[5] I find that both of your identities as nationals of Russia have been established by testimonies, as well as by copies of your national passports on file. I have assessed whether the associate claimant has access to citizenship of Uzbekistan through his mother, who was born there. And so, according to Tab 3.1of the NDP for Uzbekistan, a person is a citizen of Uzbekistan if they are born in the country and one (1) of their parents is a citizen of the Republic of Uzbekistan. A child shall acquire that citizenship only at the request of their parent, is what this information says. The associate claimant testified that his mother is not currently a citizen of Uzbekistan, and after the collapse of the Soviet Union she was only a citizen of Russia. According to have 3.8 of the NDP for Russia, Russia does not allow dual citizenship, and any other citizenship must be renounced if one wishes to acquire Russian citizenship. I find that the associate claimant testified in a credible manner about his mother’s background and citizenship, and I have no reason to doubt his testimony, and, so, based on the objective evidence, and based on the associate claimants testimony, I do accept the fact that his mother is not a citizen of Uzbekistan, and, consequently, that he has no claim either to citizenship of Uzbekistan. And so, I only assessed his claim under — his claim against his current country of nationality, which is Russia.
Credibility
[6] There is a presumption of truthfulness when a claimant swears to their testimony, unless there are any reasons to doubt it, and that presumption of truthfulness also applies to written testimony. In the present claim, I have no reason to doubt either claimant’s testimony or their truthfulness. I find that both of them testified in a heartfelt and personal manner here today about their background, and about their experiences in Russia. The claimant’s written narrative was very detailed, and it was consistent with the oral testimonies that we heard here today, as well as the other documentation that the claimants filed in support of their claims.
[7] The claimant submitted several documents in support of their claims. These included news articles and photos from when the principal claimant was on the XXXX XXXX that was mentioned, as well as witness letters from family members attesting to the principal claimant’s history and transition. The claimants did not submit any medical records about the principal claimant’s transition. However, I find that that was explained reasonably because, after being on the XXXX XXXX, and after the publicity that ensued, the doctor who handled this transition refused to send any documents electronically, and I find that was a reasonable explanation for why none of these documents were submitted. I find that the additional evidence that was submitted did support both claimants’ core allegations.
[8] And so based on your credible testimony, based on the documentation on file, and based on a balance of probabilities, I do accept as fact that the principal claimant is a transgender woman, and that the associate claimant is a bisexual man. And I also accept as fact the instances of violent attacks that they were both subjected to in Russia.
Nexus to a Convention Ground
[9] A Convention refugee is someone who has well-founded fear of persecution because of their race, their nationality, their religion, their political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. The claimants have identified their SOGIESC background as the reason they fear persecution in Russia, and I find that SOGIESC characteristics are innate characteristics, and therefore they form a particular social group. And so, I assessed both of these claims under section 96 of the Act, with a nexus to the Convention ground of membership in a particular social group.
[10] Next, I will go over the country condition information to determine whether the claimants’ fear of future harm has an objective basis. And so, that Russia is a deeply homophobic state is no secret. Tab 6.1 of the NDP for Russia covers this topic extensively. According to this report, and this report was updated in 2020, although gay relations are not criminalised in Russia as of 1999, Russia did pass a law in 2013 that bans the promotion of non-traditional sexual relations, which we will just call the Gay Propaganda Law. This law has been used to prosecute a variety of people trying to defend the human rights of sexual minorities, such as activists, people (sic) who run websites in the media. According to a report from 2018, LGBTI persons report a significant societal stigma, and discrimination which some attributed to official promotion of intolerance and homophobia. The same source indicated that state-controlled media engaged in a homophobic campaign in which officials, journalists, and others called LGBTI persons a variety of extremely derogatory terms. According to another report, a new one from 2023, which is at Tab 6.2 of the NDP. Many LGBTI people, including activists and those working in LGBTI organizations, have left Russia since the war against Ukraine broke out and the new propaganda law was adopted. Anti-LGBT hate speech was a severe issue throughout the year of 2023. For example, in April of that year, a court fined Meta and TikTok tens of thousands of euros for refusing to take down what the authorities consider to be LGBT propaganda. Several other propaganda rulings were also passed down that year. Some examples of the harm that people have experienced: there were two (2) men that were put in pre-trial detention for engaging in sex that was witnessed by a 14 year old neighbor through a window, and these men can face more than 10 years in prison in Russia; in April and October of last year, the courts upheld the prison sentences for two (2) Chechen members of the LGBTI community who had been arbitrarily arrested, and who had been subjected to psychological torture and physical abuse, and held without access to a lawyer. This report also says that hate crimes against LGBT people, including murder, physical violence, and extortion, were committed again last year, and that the authorities failed to classify them as anti-LGBTI hate crimes.
[11] You also submitted several news articles yourself to support your claim. These are found at Exhibit 4.2 of the consolidated list of documents. These news articles depict individuals being arrested for having a rainbow flag, and one (1) news article was a report on gender-affirming surgery, whereby a new law is being passed in Russia that bans trans health care and dissolves marriages for transgender people.
[12] I find the NDP that I just cited indicates that sexual diversity is not tolerated in Russian society, and that being a transgender person or bisexual person can lead to a serious risk to one’s life and health and safety, and so I have accepted as fact that both of you have been already subjected to brutal attacks due to your diverse SOGIESC background. I find, based on your personal circumstances, based on your past experiences, and based on the objective evidence, that both of you face the serious risk of persecutory acts, such as physical assault or even death, in Russia, should you return there now and live openly — live your lives openly.
[13] Lastly, I have considered whether state protection would be available to you, or whether you could relocate safely to a different area within Russia. As the state is one of the agents of persecution in the present claim, I find you cannot turn to state authorities for help, especially taking into account that you have already attempted to get help from police, but that help was not forthcoming. As well, there is no indication in the objective evidence that there is any area within Russia where individuals with diverse SOGIESC could live openly and be safe, and so I find that you have access neither to state protection nor an internal flight alternative within your home country.
CONCLUSION
[14] And so, based on the evidence provided, and for the reasons I just stated, I find that you both meet the definition of a Convention refugee per 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act of Canada, and your claims for protection are therefore accepted.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
