2024 RLLR 146
Citation: 2024 RLLR 146
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: February 6, 2024
Panel: Hannah Gray
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Peter R Neill
Country: Ukraine
RPD Number: VC3-08132
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-00724
ATIP Pages: N/A
DECISION
[1] MEMBER: This is the decision of the Refugee Protection Division, the RPD, in the claim of XXXX XXXX, the claimant, a citizen of Ukraine who is claiming refugee protection pursuant to section 96 and subsection 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, the IRPA. In this hearing and in making this decision, I have considered and applied the Chairperson’s Guideline on sexual orientation and gender identity and expression and sex characteristics.
DETERMINATION
[2] I find that the claimant is a Convention refugee pursuant to section 96 of the IRPA based on his well-founded fear of persecution in Ukraine.
ALLEGATIONS
[3] The specifics of the claim are stated in the claimant’s Basis of Claim form and narrative, as well as his amended narrative in evidence. The claimant is a 25-year-old bisexual man from Chernivtsi, Ukraine. When he was around 15 years old, the claimant faced discrimination from his father when he found that the claimant was looking at gay porn. In February 2021, the claimant met another bisexual man, named XXXX, and they began a relationship. The claimant was also in a relationship with a woman, XXXX, at this time and he had intentions to marry her. However, he did not tell XXXX about his fiancée or the person that he had planned to marry until March 2021. And at this time, the relationship ended between the claimant and his same-sex partner. When the claimant and his same-sex partner were at a club, when their relationship had ended, they were both assaulted in public due to the claimant’s partner’s wilful display of affection. Soon after, the claimant returned to his fiancée, XXXX, after he had recovered from his injuries. However, his fiancée had found out that the claimant was bisexual and then the claimant was attacked by her brother and their relationship also ended, and he continued to receive threats over the phone from her brother.
[4] The claimant then returned to his hometown around XXXX 2021 and his father informed him that the military had come to enlist the claimant in the conscription for the military in Ukraine. The claimant avoided being drafted and decided to flee after a subpoena was issued to him. He left Ukraine illegally as he is an eligible man who is not allowed to leave Ukraine at this time due to his age, which fits in the age for the forced conscription. The claimant left Ukraine in XXXX 2022 and then went to Romania and stayed in Italy for a few months and then came to Canada on the CUAET visa. The claimant entered Canada in XXXX 2022 and made his refugee claim in January 2023. The claimant fears the homophobic policies and persecution towards LGBTQ+ persons in Ukraine. He also fears returning to Ukraine due to the forced conscription as he is in military age.
ANALYSIS
Identity
[5] The claimant’s personal identity and his identity as a national of Ukraine has been established by his sworn testimony and the certified copy of his passport in evidence in Exhibit 1. I accept that the claimant is a national of Ukraine and no other country.
Credibility
[6] When a claimant swears the truth of their allegations, this creates a presumption that those allegations are true unless there is reason to doubt their truthfulness. I find no reason to doubt the truthfulness of the claimant. He testified in a straightforward, forthright, detailed and candid manner, and there were no material inconsistencies, omissions or contradictions between the claimant’s testimony and the other evidence in this case that were not reasonably explained. He did not exaggerate or tailor his evidence, and in summary, his testimony was consistent with the other evidence on the central aspects of his claim. I find the claimant provided ample details to expand upon his allegations, and he also provided evidence in Exhibit 4, which included a letter from XXXX XXXX organisation regarding the claimant’s membership and a donation he made, e-mail support from XXXX XXXX and more information regarding XXXX XXXX organisation. He also included photographs of himself at a Pride event in Canada and support letters from XXXX XXXX, who was his former same-sex partner in Ukraine, a support letter from his friend, XXXX XXXX XXXX a friend from Canada, and a support letter and ID from XXXX XXXX who is the claimant’s former same-sex partner in Canada. The claimant provided a medical report from XXXX 2021, which was after he was attacked in a nightclub with his former partner from Ukraine. The claimant also provided photographs of the claimant with his male partner in Ukraine as well as his female partner in Ukraine, and photographs of himself with his ex-boyfriend and gay friend in Canada.
[7] The claimant also provided a number of country condition articles on the treatment of LGBTQ2+ people in Ukraine. I have no reason to doubt the genuineness of these documents, and since these documents do relate to the claimant’s same-sex relationships in both Ukraine and Canada and the issues he faced in Ukraine, I place significant weight on these documents to support his claim. Given the claimant’s careful testimony and supporting documents, I find he has established on a balance of probabilities the facts alleged in his claim, including that he is a bisexual man from Ukraine who faced threats and assaults in Ukraine in the past due to his sexual orientation and who is currently the age for military conscription and, therefore, fled Ukraine illegally. In sum, I find the claimant to be a credible witness and believe what he has alleged in support of his claim.
Nexus
[8] To qualify for refugee status under the Refugee Convention, an individual must demonstrate that they have a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. The allegations establish a nexus to the Convention ground for the claimant based on his membership in a particular social group due to his sexual orientation as a bisexual man and I will, therefore, assess his claim under section 96.
Well-Founded Fear of Persecution and Risk of Harm
[9] I find the claimant has a well-founded fear of persecution in Ukraine based on his sexual orientation. The National Documentation Package for Ukraine describes Ukraine as a society that continues to harbour significant anti-LGBTQ2+ sentiment despite some signs of change. NDP Item 6.1 states that, since the onset of the war, LGBTQ civilians have reported countless incidents where they faced harassment and violence at checkpoints where the police or the army or the territorial defence checked their documents and personal belongings. NDP Item 6.2 states that police also committed violence against LGBTIQ2+ people. Victims rarely appealed to public associations that protect the rights of LGBTIQ2+ people, and in about half the cases, they did not get help from them. NDP Item 2.1 establishes that there was societal violence against LGBTIQ2+ persons, often perpetrated by members of violent radical groups, and authorities often did not adequately investigate these cases or hold perpetrators to account.
[10] Further, I note the Freedom House report at NDP Item 2.3, which indicates that LGBTIQ2+ people experience significant societal discrimination and generally do not receive protection from attacks against them. I find that the claimant himself has established that the ongoing violence towards this community, including the violence the claimant has personally suffered himself amounts to persecution. Therefore, the claimant has established a well-founded fear of persecution due to his sexual orientation as a bisexual man if he were to return to Ukraine now. In making this finding, I also note that Guideline 9 reminds Members that it is well established in law that being compelled to conceal one’s SOGIESC identity constitutes a serious interference with fundamental human rights that may, therefore, amount to persecution, and a claimant cannot be expected to conceal their identity as a way to avoid persecution in their country of reference. I find that, given there is no indication that the conditions have improved in the country of Ukraine and, in fact, have gotten worse since the Russian invasion, that the claimant would face more than a mere possibility of persecution if he were to return to Ukraine now.
State Protection and Internal Flight Alternative
[11] In all refugee claims, a state is presumed to be capable of protecting its citizens unless there is clear and convincing evidence to the contrary. In this case, I find this presumption has been rebutted. To rebut this presumption, a claimant must establish on a balance of probabilities through clear and convincing evidence that their state’s protection is inadequate and the onus is on the claimant to do this. The Ukraine NDP at Item 6.5, which was published prior to the Russian invasion, states that “the police are extremely reluctant to investigate cases in homophobic and transphobic crime. Most of the victims do not report attacks to the police, as they do not trust the system, fear harassment and violence from the police, or having to divulge information about their sexual orientation. The absence of an effective investigation and relevant legal categorisation of these offences as hate crimes sends a clear message about impunity for such crimes.” And while country documents indicate that police have shown some initial signs of improvement in their treatment of the LGBTIQ2+ people, there are still homophobic incidents and the situation has not improved significantly.
[12] Currently, Ukraine is at war with Russia since the Russian invasion began in late February 2022. In the Ukraine-held territory, I am satisfied that the state continues to fail to provide adequate and effective protection in any consistent manner to LGBTIQ2+ people as detailed above. Furthermore, NDP Item 2.1 states that, when the Russians occupied Crimea, most LGBTIQ2+ individuals fled and those who remained lived in fear of abuse due to their sexual orientation or gender identity. The UN Human Rights Council’s independent expert received reports of increased violence and discrimination against the LGBTIQ2+ community in Crimea, as well as the use of homophobic propaganda employed by the occupation authorities. Therefore, I am satisfied that, now with the invasion of Ukraine by Russia, there is an increased threat to any LGBTIQ2+ people in any part of the country that may fall under Russian control. If Crimea is any indication, things will be much worse in any areas that fall under Russian control, with the state being an active agent of persecution. Accordingly, I find there is no adequate state protection available to the claimant and I find the presumption of state protection has been rebutted.
[13] Now to speak to Internal Flight Alternative, the state of Ukraine is no longer in control of all of its territories, and where the Russians have taken over, the situation is even more dire for LGBTIQ2+ people. Therefore, I find that the claimant faces a serious possibility of persecution throughout Ukraine and there is no viable Internal Flight Alternative available to him.
CONCLUSION
[14] For these reasons, I find the claimant is a Convention refugee under section 96 of the Act and I accept his claim.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
