2024 RLLR 166

Citation: 2024 RLLR 166
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: January 3, 2024
Panel: Liyusew Kidane
Counsel for the Claimant(s): David Vago
Country: Hungary
RPD Number: TC3-15742
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A

DECISION

[1]       MEMBER: We are back on the record.

DECISION

[2] This is a decision for XXXX XXXX, file number TC3-15742. I have considered your testimony and the other evidence in this claim, and I am ready to render my decision orally.

[3] You allege to be a citizen of Hungary and are seeking refugee protection pursuant to Sections 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.

DETERMINATION

[4] I find you to be a Convention refugee as you’ve established you face a serious possibility of persecution in Hungary due to your Roma ethnicity.

ALLEGATIONS

[5] The details of your allegations are found in your Basis of Claim form. In summary, you allege to have been subjected to violence, inequal and discriminatory treatment in many aspects of your life in Hungary including employment, education, housing, and accessing public spaces. You allege you will face discrimination in these areas if you were to return to Hungary and the, you claim you would be mistreated and discriminated because of your Roma ethnicity.

Identity

[6] You have established your national identity as a Hungarian national through your testimony and a certified true copy of your Hungarian passport found in Exhibit 1 and a copy of your birth certificate found in Exhibit 7.

Credibility

[7] I find you to be a credible witness. Your testimony was straightforward, spontaneous, detailed, and consistent with your narrative and the documentary evidence. You testified that you belong to a Roma ethnic group, and you can be identified as such in Hungary based on your last name, XXXX, the colour of your skin, and your accent and (inaudible). You testified that your last name is commonly used by Roma in Hungary.

[8] You corroborated your Roma identity by providing a copy of the RPD decision that accepted your brother’s refugee claim in Canada on the basis of the discrimination he experienced in Hungary due to his Roma ethnicity. This document is found in Exhibit 5. Therefore, I find that you have provided sufficient and credible evidence to establish your Roma ethnicity.

[9] You also provided credible testimony regarding how you were a victim of racially motivated physical attacks in Hungary. You testified about the discrimination you experienced in accessing and maintaining employment. You also testified about the bias discrimination you experienced in accessing public spaces including being profiled by the police, followed by security guards while shopping, and denied entry into restaurants and other entertainment venues, and while using public transportation.

[10] Having considered your testimony and the documentary evidence, I find that you have established on a balance of probabilities that you experienced violence and discrimination in Hungry in accessing education, employment, housing, and public spaces due to your Roma ethnicity.

[11] You have established that you fear you will continue to face similar incidents of violence and discrimination should you return to Hungary. Therefore, you have established a subjective fear of facing violence and discrimination in Hungary due to your Roma ethnic, ethnicity in many aspects of your life including employment, housing, healthcare, and accessing public spaces.

Objective Evidence

[12] I find your experience of discriminatory treatment is similar with the experience of other Roma in Hungary.

[13] According to report found in tab 13.15 in the NDP for Hungary, the Committee on Elimination of Racial Discrimination continued to express high concern at the persistence of discrimination against Roma. The committee noted that systemic discrimination against Roma persisted across many sectors including in healthcare, education, housing, and employment, and the Roma are subjected to racial profiling by law enforcement officers and hate speech against Roma has persisted including from public officials.

[14] According to Minority Rights International Group Report found in tab 13.11 in the NDP, Roma community in Hungary continues to suffer profound social and economic marginalization including higher level of poverty and unemployment and is also a prime target of ethnically motivated attacks.

[15] According to tab 13.5, Roma in Hungary face discrimination in all aspects of life including education, housing, employment, healthcare, and political participation; for example, the employment rates of Roma were three (3) to five (5) times higher than that of non-Roma population.

[16] Therefore, I find that your experience is similar with the situations of members of the Roma community in Hungary.

Well-Foundedness of Your Fear of Persecution

[17] Considering the cumulative effects of what you experienced and will continue to experience upon your return to Hungary, your personal circumstances in the context of country conditions, I find that you face a serious possibility of persecution in Hungary due to your Roma ethnicity.

[18] In terms of your personal circumstances, I find the increased risk of discrimination in the future. You have limited education and employment experience and I find this affects your ability to get housing and secure stable life.

[19] With respect to the country condition, I note that the government has been making efforts to improve the situation of Roma; however, the country condition information shows that currently the general climate in Hungary for Roma is still rife with discrimination and its one which the government is creating a situation of insecurity for Roma people. When I consider the country conditions, your personal circumstances, your, and your past experience of discrimination cumulatively, I find that you face an insecure future with regard to accessing employment, housing, medical care, and public spaces in Hungary. Therefore, I find that the cumulative discrimination that you have experienced and will continue to experience upon your return to Hungary is rife with serious possibility of persecution. Therefore, you have established a well-founded fear of persecution in Hungary.

State Protection

[20] According to tab 13.11, Roma people persistently face hostility and discrimination from the police forces and adequate state protection is often not available to them. I note that Hungary is a multi-party parliamentary democracy, the police receive anti-discrimination training, there exists an ombudsperson and an independent police complaint board; however, the evidence indicates weakness in the Hungary democratic institutions. Over the last decade, the rise of nationalism has gradually undermined the rule of law and democratic institutions in Hungary.

[21] The objective evidence indicates that the government has initiated some programs to improve the lives of Roma people in Hungary; however, on a balance of probabilities, I find that these efforts have not translated into effective state protection on the oppressional level for you; therefore, I conclude that the state is unable to provide adequate protection to you and you have rebutted the presumption of state protection.

Internal Flight Alternative

[22] I find that you face a serious possibility of persecution throughout Hungary as the systemic discriminatory treatment of Roma people by the state and society is present throughout the country. Therefore, I find that you have no viable Internal Flight Alternative.

CONCLUSION

[23] Based on the above analysis, I find you to be a Convention refugee and I accept your claim.


——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———