2024 RLLR 60
Citation: 2024 RLLR 60
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: December 4, 2024
Panel: Olukunle Ojeleye
Counsel for the Claimant(s): James Darrell Hayes
Country: Occupied Palestinian Territory
RPD Number: VC4-00468
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-00128
ATIP Pages: N/A
REASONS FOR DECISION
INTRODUCTION
[1] These are the reasons for the decision in the refugee claim of XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX, who alleges to be a stateless resident of the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT) and is seeking protection pursuant to sections 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA).[1]
[2] This claim has been decided without a hearing, according to the Immigration and Refugee Board’s Chairperson’s Instructions Governing the Streaming of Less Complex Claims at the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) and paragraph 170(f) of the Act.
[3] In deciding the claim, the panel has considered all of the evidence before it, including the Basis of Claim (BOC) form,[2] the referral documents,[3] the country-of-origin information contained within the National Documentation Package (NDP)[4] and the claimant’s documentary evidence.[5]
ALLEGATIONS
[4] The claimant’s allegations are contained in his Basis of Claim (BOC) form and the attached narrative.[6] In summary, the claimant fear persecution and harm in the West Bank of the Occupied Palestinian Territory (OPT), given his experience of aggression from the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and Israeli settlers.
[5] The claimant is from a well-known family in the West bank that XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX. The family also owned land. As a result of their prominence and objection to Israeli policies of encroachment and seizure of Palestinian land, they have become targets of the IDF and Israeli settlers.
[6] In XXXX 2021, the claimant’s friend was shot and killed by the IDF. In XXXX 2021, the claimant’s older brother was taken from his home by the IDF and was detained for about XXXX XXXX during which he was tortured.
[7] The claimant began to experience incessant delays, harassment and questioning at checkpoints. His personal properties and that of his family became targets of arsonist.
[8] Fearful for his life, the claimant decided to flee the West Bank. He obtained a visa to Canada in XXXX 2023 and fled the West Bank in XXXX 2023. On arrival in Canda, the claimant made an application for protection.
DETERMINATION
[9] The panel finds that the claimant is a Convention refugee pursuant to section 96 of the Act.
ANALYSIS
Identity
[10] The claimant’s personal identity, and identity as a stateless Palestinian is established by a copy of his passport issued by the Palestinian Authority.[7]
Countries of Former Habitual Residence (CFHR)
[11] Under section 96 of the Act, the definition of a Convention refugee is: a person who, by reason of a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group or political opinion,
(a) is outside each of their countries of nationality and is unable or, by reason of that fear, unwilling to avail themself of the protection of each of those countries; or
(b) not having a country of nationality, is outside the country of their former habitual residence and is unable or, by reason of that fear, unwilling to return to that country.
[12] A consideration of former habitual residence is only relevant where the claimant is stateless.[8] A stateless person is someone who is not recognized by any country as a citizen.[9] The courts have consistently upheld the principle set out in Maarouf[10] whereby a claimant does not have to be able to legally return to a country of former habitual residence for the country to be considered one of former habitual residence.
[13] Based on the evidence before the panel, the claimant does not have a country of nationality. The claimant was born in the West Bank and lived all his life there before living OPT for XXXX where he flew to Canada.
[14] The evidence before the panel also indicates that the claimant only transited through XXXX and did not obtain any continuing residence of significant duration that would have been sufficient to establish de facto residence.
[15] Therefore, the panel finds that XXXX is not a country of former habitual residence for the claimant.
[16] The panel finds that the West Bank and OPT is the only place of former habitual residence for the claimant.
Nexus
[17] To qualify for refugee status under the Refugee Convention, an individual must demonstrate that they have a well-founded fear of persecution “for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion”.[11]
[18] The claimant alleges that he cannot return to occupied Palestine because the Israeli armed forces and Israeli settlers have targeted him as a Palestinian living in the West Bank in a struggle over land.
[19] The panel finds that the claimants’ allegations have a nexus to the convention ground of nationality, and the convention ground of membership of a particular social group as Palestinians in the OPT.
[20] The panel therefore assessed the claim under section 96 of the IRPA.
Credibility
[21] When a claimant swears to the truth of allegations, this creates a presumption that those allegations are true unless there is a valid reason to doubt their truthfulness.[12] However, this presumption does not extend to inferences, which are conclusions from facts, or speculation, which are allegations without any evidentiary basis.
[22] The panel finds the claimant’s written and signed narrative sufficiently detailed and coherent. Based on the documents in the file, the panel has noted no serious credibility issues. In particular, the claimant provided corroborating documents[13] which include:
- Identification documents that corroborate the claimant’s Nablus origin as a Palestinian in the OPT.
- Pictures of damages to the claimant’s XXXX corroborating his allegations of the family business being targeted by the Israeli security forces and settlers.
- Letters of support from the claimant’s older brother, XXXX XXXX and the claimant’s neighbour, XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX corroborating the experiences of the claimant in the OPT, and the circumstances that resulted in his decision to seek safety and refuge in Canada.
After reviewing the documents, the panel has no reason to doubt their authenticity.
[23] Overall, the panel finds that the claimant has established a subjective basis to his well-founded fear of persecution if he were to return to the OPT.
Forward Looking Risk
[24] When assessing a claim for refugee protection, the panel must consider whether the claimant has a well-founded fear of persecution which involves both a subjective fear element and an objective basis for that fear.
[25] The law is very clear that the definition of Convention refugee is forward-looking. As articulated by the Federal Court of Appeal in Mileva, “[t]he question raised by a claim to refugee status is not whether the claimant had reason to fear persecution in the past, but rather whether he now, at the time his claim is being decided, has good grounds to fear persecution in the future.”[14]
[26] Given that there are no serious credibility issues with respect to the claimant’s allegations, coupled with the documentary evidence set out below, the panel finds that the claimant has established a prospective risk of persecution and harm in occupied Palestine and the West Bank.
[27] The experience of the claimant in regard to the family’s ancestral land is corroborated by objective evidence that Israel has denied Palestinians access to 35% of the agricultural land in the OPT.” [15]
[28] Objective evidence indicates that the government of Israel occupies the West Bank and in maintaining a security presence and effective control, Israeli security agencies have reportedly committed unlawful or arbitrary killings of Palestinians.[16]
[29] The claimant’s allegation of harassment at internal checkpoints is underlined by objective evidence that “mobility in and out of Gaza, between Gaza and the West Bank, and within the West Bank is greatly restricted by bureaucratic processes and checkpoints”.[17] Further reports indicate that “Israel set up checkpoints for facial scans and identity checks, where fleeing Palestinians were often detained and later mistreated and tortured”.[18]
[30] Based on the totality of the evidence, the panel finds that the claimant has established an objectively well-founded fear of persecution and harm if he returns to occupied Palestine and the West Bank.
State Protection
[31] There is a presumption that a state, if it is in control of its territory, will make serious efforts to protect its citizens. Failure to seek protection from authorities can be fatal to a claim and it is up to claimants to rebut the presumption of state protection with clear and convincing evidence that the state cannot or will not protect them.
[32] The evidence in this claim is that the West Bank is occupied militarily by the Israeli armed forces which has targeted Palestinian civilians in what has been described as war crimes, and whose behaviour towards the Palestinians has been described as one of apartheid which amount to persecution.[19]
[33] Since the Israeli state is the agent of persecution and harm, the panel finds that state protection for the claimant would not be reasonably forthcoming from Israeli authorities.
[34] The panel finds that the presumption of state protection is rebutted in this claim.
Internal Flight Alternative
[35] The panel also considered whether a viable internal flight alternative exists for the claimant.
[36] Objective evidence already cited notes that Israel imposes severe restrictions on the movement of Palestinians within the occupied territory. Such restrictions include numerous checkpoints, internal road closures, and prohibition of the free movement of people in and out of the West Bank.
[37] Given the objective evidence, the panel therefore finds that there is no viable internal flight alternative for the claimant within occupied Palestine and the West Bank.
CONCLUSION
[38] For the aforementioned reasons, the panel finds that the claimant has established that he is a Convention refugee as set out in section 96 of the Act. The panel therefore accepts his claim.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
[1] Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, S.C. 2001, c. 27.
[2] Exhibit 2.
[3] Exhibit 1.
[4] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024.
[5] Exhibit 4.
[6] Exhibit 2.
[7] Exhibit 1.
[8] Choudry, Robin v. M.C.I. (F.C., no. IMM-2353-11), Russell, December 2, 2011, 2011 FC 1406.
[9] Lin, Yu Hong v. M.C.I. (F.C.T.D., no. IMM-1855-94), Reed, December 12, 1994
[10] Maarouf v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1994] 1 F.C. 723 (T.D.); (1993), 23 Imm. L.R. (2d) 163 (F.C.T.D).
[11] UN General Assembly, Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, 28 July 1951, United Nations.
[12] Maldonado v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1980] 2 F.C. 302 (C.A.)
[13] Exhibit 4.
[14] Mileva v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1991] 3 F.C. 398 (C.A.) at para 8.
[15] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024, tab 2.30: Economic and social repercussions of the Israeli occupation on the living conditions of the Palestinian people in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and of the Arab population in the occupied Syrian Golan. Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights. 30 June 2023. A/78/127-E/2023/95.
[16] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024, tab 2.1: West Bank and Gaza. Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2023.. United States. Department of State. 22 April 2024.
[17] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024, tab 1.5: Palestine: Social impacts of the humanitarian situation. Assessment Capacities Project. 19 October 2021.
[18] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024, tab 1.2: Anatomy of a Genocide: Report of the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967, Francesca Albanese. United Nations. Human Rights Council. 25 March 2024. A/HRC/55/73.
[19] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package, Palestinian Territory, Occupied, 31 May 2024, tab 2.2: Palestine (State of). Amnesty International Report 2023/24: The State of the World’s Human Rights.. Amnesty International. 23 April 2024. POL 10/7200/2024.
