2024 RLLR 157
Citation: 2024 RLLR 157
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: August 15, 2024
Panel: Olamide Daramola
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Nicholas Woodward
Country: Jordan
RPD Number: TC3-43697
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A
DECISION
[1] MEMBER: This is a decision of the refugee protection in the claim of XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX. You claim to be a citizen of Jordan, born in Palestine, and you are claiming refugee protection, pursuant to section 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. The file number is TC3-43697.
[2] The date is August 15, 2024. I have considered your testimony and the other evidence in this case, and I am ready to render my decision orally. I will be giving you this decision. The transcript will be sent to you and your Counsel.
[3] In assessing this claim, I have considered and applied the Chairperson’s Guideline 9, which deals with Proceedings Before the IRB Involving Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity and Expression, and Sex Characteristics. And this is to ensure the appropriate accommodations were made in questioning the claimant in the overall hearing process and in substantively assessing the claim. This is also to ensure fairness and equality in the hearing room.
DETERMINATION
[4] Based upon the totality of the oral and documentary evidence before me, I find that you are a Convention refugee under section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, as you will face a serious possibility of persecution by reasons of your membership in particular social group, as a gay man in Jordan.
ALLEGATIONS
[5] Your allegations are fully set out in the Basis of Claim form. To summarize, you allege that you fear persecution in Jordan and Palestine at the hands of your family, the state agents, and the society in general because you are a gay man. You allege you left Jordan also because your family are forcing you into marriage. You further allege that you are unable to live freely in Jordan, or even in Palestine, as you will be subjected to threats and violence due to your sexual orientation.
Country of Reference
[6] I note that you were born in XXXX, West Bank in Palestine, and that you stated that you hold a national ID for Palestine. When I asked you about your national ID for Palestine and why you have not submitted it in evidence, you explained that all documents are in a folder in your parents’ room, and that you would raise questions if you were to request for it. You testified that your parents are not aware that you are seeking protection in Canada, as they understand that you are here to study. You explained that it would also be a risk for you to request this document as they also do not know your sexual orientation.
[7] I do find your explanation to be reasonable in your particular situation regarding your sexual orientation, which you have yet to disclose to your family.
[8] You also have in your possession an internationally recognized passport from Jordan, which ostensibly recognizes you as a Jordanian citizen with a national number, although you were born in Palestine. You have testified that you can only remember going to Palestine to secure your national ID in 2016, upon your mother’s request, and a few other times, and you have lived your whole life in Jordan. I therefore find that Jordan — sorry. Just a minute.
[9] My screen just froze. So, just give me a minute, okay?
[10] Okay. Sorry. Thank you for your patience. I will now continue my decision.
[11] Okay. So, therefore, I find that Jordan is the only country of reference in this claim, as the Immigration and Refugee Board only considers Palestine as a place of arbitrary residence when the claimant has no other citizenship, which is not the case here. The claimant has not been found to be a stateless Palestinian. Therefore, I have not considered Palestine as a place of formal arbitrary residence in this case.
[12] The claimant’s claim would only be assessed against Jordan.
Identity
[13] I find that you have established your personal and national identity as a citizen of Jordan, on a balance of probabilities, by your testimony and the documentary evidence on file, including a certified true copy of your Jordanian passport, which can be found at Exhibit 1.
Nexus
[14] The foregoing allegations establish that you face a fear of persecution due to your sexual orientation, as a gay man in Jordan. I find that there is a nexus between the harm that you fear and one (1) of the five (5) Refugee Convention grounds, which is membership in a particular social group. And I will be assessing your claim on the membership in a particular social group, as a gay man, under section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, because this is determinative of your claim.
Credibility
[15] Credibility is central to all refugee claims. The court ruled in Maldonado v. Canada that the sworn testimony of the claimant is presumed to be true, unless there is a reason to doubt its truthfulness. In making this assessment, I have considered all the evidence, including the oral testimony and the documents submitted by your Counsel and entered as Exhibit 6. I have also considered your level of education and cognizance of difficulties faced by individuals in establishing their claims, including the cultural factor, the milieu of the hearing room, the stress in responding to questions put to them.
[16] However, I have found that you have established, on a balance of probabilities, your allegations, and I find them to be credible. I also find that you were a credible witness. I find that your testimony was straightforward and consistent with your narrative and the documents that you have provided. I — there were no inconsistencies or omissions. You are able to provide the kind of details one would expect from someone telling their own story.
[17] You stated you are from a conservative and devout Muslim family.
[18] You explained what being gay meant to you, which is that you are a guy who is attracted only to males and not attracted at all to females. You candidly described when you realized your sexual orientation at the age of 10. You explained that you had a friend named MS (ph), who is about a year or two (2) years older than you. You developed a close friendship after he approached you at recess, and you both jokingly touched each other sexually. You stated that this act took place in a private location of the school’s washroom. You stated that this act with MS made you feel happy, but also confused at the same time as you felt that it contradicted your religion as a Muslim.
[19] You explained that it was after your encounters with MS you developed more interest towards men. You stated that you could not tell anyone about this, as you were terrified, as you were told in your religious class that any gay person would be stoned. You also stated that you did not disclose it to your parents due to the current state of health of your parents, and you would not be able to live with the guilt if something happened to them after getting to know about your sexual orientation.
[20] You testified that you read the Quran (inaudible) it would help, but it did not due to the stories in the Quran about a town being flooded due to men having same-sex relationships. You explained that this freaked you out.
[21] You stated having the need to explore your sexual orientation. So, you started watching pornography.
[22] I find you have credibly established, on a balance of probabilities, and described in detail your understanding of your realization of your sexual orientation as a gay man.
[23] I also accept your evidence regarding you dating and being in several same-sex relationships in the past. You candidly describe how you met your current same-sex partner, MA (ph), in XXXX 2021, after your trip from Türkiye through the (inaudible) dating app. You were able to explain your attractions and also how you were both able to keep your relationships in secret. You explained that your partner lost his parents and during that time you were supportive of him. And so, at that point, you both knew you were meant for each other. You both still call each other to celebrate the XXXX of every month as the date you met each other.
[24] You explained that it is been difficult since you arrived in Canada, as you both missed each other, and you decided to (inaudible) the relationship. You told me about your future plans together, which is for him to be here. You both talk about getting engaged someday or even get married.
[25] You supported your testimony with the letter from MA and photos of the both of you in Amman, which can be found at Exhibit 6. Upon careful review, I find no reason to doubt the authenticity of this document, as it corroborates the core allegations of your claim and the status of your relationship with MA.
[26] I find that you have also been able to describe your relationship with MA. I find that it is in keeping with one who was — who is in a same-sex relationship. Therefore, I find that you have credibly established, on a balance of probabilities, that you were in same-sex relationship, and you are still in the same-sex relationship with MA.
[27] You explained that since you arrived in Canada in XXXX 2022 and did not initiate your claim for protection until June 2023. I was concerned about this delay in claiming and as to why you did not also claim at the port of entry. You explained that you did not know you could seek protection. You also explained that it is scary and terrifying if anyone finds out about you seeking protection, as they could contact your family.
[28] I do accept your explanation as reasonable. I also find that you are still in status in Canada as a student and on a valid student visa. I do not draw any negative credibility inference from your lack of disclosure at the port of entry with respect to your claim for protection.
[29] I have also applied the Chairperson Guideline 9.
[30] And particularly, in the case of Gabila v. Canada, Citizenship Immigration. The citation is 2016 FC 574. Paragraph 31 to 32, the Court has noted that it was understandable in that case that the applicant has substituted a (inaudible) for the truth at the port of entry, as they did (inaudible) his sexual orientation in his own country, and was fearful of disclosing his sexual orientation to authorities upon his arrival in Canada.
[31] You also provided in support of your testimony documents which can be found at Exhibit 6, which includes, but not limited to, letters from some of your friends here in Canada confirming your sexual orientation, a screenshot of your (inaudible) chat, pictures of you at the Pride parade, the gay clubs in Toronto, and with gay friends skiing at the XXXX XXXX XXXX.
[32] Upon careful review, I note the pictures and contents of the chat show intimacy with the — with same-sex people. I have no reason to doubt their authenticity. I attach full weigh to the documents, as it corroborates your testimony and your claim. You — and I find that you have now fully embraced your gay sexual orientation and identity, and that you live freely as a gay man here in Canada.
[33] In conclusion, regarding credibility, I accept as credible that you are a gay man, and that if you should return to Jordan and try to live freely or openly, you will face persecution or violence because of your sexual orientation. And based upon the evidence provided, I find, on a balance of probabilities, that you have established your subjective fear of persecution on the ground of your sexual orientation as a gay man in Canada and in Jordan.
Objective Evidence
[34] Exhibit 3, which is the objective evidence for the National — with respect to the National Documentation Package for Jordan supports your credible testimony.
[35] The NDP for Jordan confirms that those who are perceived to be members of a sexual and minority in the country, such as yourself, face persecution there.
[36] Item 2.4 of the NDP at page 15 documents discrimination against members of the LGBTQ+ community in Jordan, and it says it is prevalent and it includes threats of violence. This intolerance is systematic and institutionalized within Jordan and with the NDP also noting that in court, the authorities have denied registration to NGOs that support LGBTQ+ rights.
[37] The NDP Item 7.3 and 2.1 also states that violence against lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and intersex persons remains a significant human rights issue for the country, according to the international human rights group.
[38] The NDP for Jordan also highlights how a person in Jordan will be subjected to persecution and violence from family members due to their different sexual orientation. It says that the name and the pride of the tribe and the family comes before everything. LGBTQ people are viewed as a stain on the honour of the tribe and the family. This can be found at Item 6.1 of the NDP.
[39] The same objective evidence makes reference to an article titled, Jordan 2020 Economic Safety Reports — that in Jordan, family members who discover a relative as LGBTQ may target them for honour crimes, with violence within the tribe and family members, which remains a deep concern.
[40] Now, while same-sex contact is not illegal in Jordan, the NDP 6.18 at page 1 documents that in the public sphere, discriminatory language and policies against the LGBTQ+ community continue to be adopted by the Jordanian government.
[41] So, based on the objective country documentation for Jordan cited above and your credible testimony, I find that if you return to Jordan, you would more than likely face a serious possibility of persecution as a gay man. And accordingly, based on the evidence provided, I find that your subjective fear of persecution is objectively well-founded.
State Protection
[42] The NDP also confirmed that state protection is not available to gay men in Jordan. As noted above, the state authorities do not provide protection to gay men and are in fact documented in the document — objective evidence to be involved in the harassment, intimidation, and arrest. So, based upon the evidence and the objective evidence from the NDP, showing the authorities do not provide adequate state protection at an operational level to the LGBTQ+ community, I find, on a balance of probabilities, that the presumption of state protection is rebutted in your case.
Internal Flight Alternative
[43] There are two (2) prongs to the IFA test. Both must be met for an IFA. In essence, the prongs are whether a proposed IFA is safe, and the second is where the proposed IFA is reasonable.
[44] Unfortunately, the conditions of intolerance, potential violence, and official systemic discrimination against members of the LGBTQ+ community in Jordan persist throughout the country and are entrenched and widespread.
[45] The objective country conditions for Jordan indicate that negative social attitudes and violence towards sexual minorities is widespread throughout the nation, without adequate protection or intervention from the state.
[46] You testified that in Jordan, the society reacts to the notion of sexual orientation, as well as you also testified as not being able to even reveal your sexual orientation to your friends in order not to be criticized by them. You tried to live as a straight man in order to hide your sexual orientation.
[47] I also rely on the Chairperson’s Guideline 9 at section 8.7.1, that it is well established in law that an IFA is not viable if a SOGIESC individual must conceal their SOGIESC in order to live in that location.
[48] And as such, I find there is nowhere in the country where you can go as a gay man and live openly and safely. Therefore, I find, on a balance of probabilities, that you do not have a viable internal flight alternative in Jordan, and that you will face a serious possibility of persecution everywhere in Jordan.
CONCLUSION
[49] Based upon the totality of evidence before me, I conclude that you face a serious possibility of persecution as a gay man everywhere in Jordan. Therefore, I find you are a Convention refugee, under section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, and I therefore accept your claim.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
