2024 RLLR 164

Citation: 2024 RLLR 164
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: July 24, 2024
Panel: Raajveer Puri
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Jordan Duviner
Country: China
RPD Number: TC2-22292
Associated RPD Number(s): TC2-22300, TC2-22305
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A

DECISION

[1]       MEMBER: Okay. This is the case for refugee protection made by XXXX XXXX, the principal claimant, and the associate claimants. The date of the hearing is 24th July 2024 and that is also the date of this, this decision.

[2] Okay. XXXX XXXX, XXXX XXXX, XXXX XXXX are Convention refugees, and your claims are accepted. XXXX XXXX and the associated claimants claim to be citizens of China. XXXX XXXX is the wife of the principal claimant and XXXX XXXX is the daughter of both adult claimants.

[3] You have asked for Canada’s protection. You allege that the Chinese state authorities will detain, torture, and harm you and your family due to your practice of Falun Gong. XXXX XXXX was appointed as the designated representative of XXXX XXXX.

[4] You have established your identities on a balance of probabilities. This means I believe it’s more likely than not that you are who you say you are. You established this through your testimony and documents, specifically your passports, national identity cards, birth certificate, household register, and marriage certificate. There is a link between what you fear, and one of the five (5) grounds listed in the refugee Convention. Specifically, I find that your claim is connected to your religion, Falun Gong. Since your claims are linked to a protective ground, I must determine whether you face a serious possibility of persecution in China. Despite some issues, you proved important parts of your refugee claims.

[5] I find that it is more likely than not that what you say happened to you in China did happen. Your testimony was straightforward and detailed. You testified about how you started practicing Falun Gong to cure your lower back injury after other remedies had failed and how you transitioned from being reluctant about Falun Gong due to being illegal in China to attending regular group sessions of Falun Gong and how when your group was discovered by the police, you fled your country because it was outlawed by the government.

[6] Except when noted below, there were no important omissions or inconsistencies in the principal claimant’s testimony or contradictions between that testimony and the other evidence before me which have not been satisfactorily explained.

[7] The first issue is your return to China. In XXXX 2019 after initially coming to Canada to freely practice Falun Gong, you returned to China in XXXX 2019 and remained there until XXXX 2022. You explained the reason for your return was because your father notified you that he had cancer and was not going to survive much longer. Your father passed away in XXXX 2020 and you remained in China due to the COVID-19 lockdowns at the time. During this time, you testified that you continued to practice Falun Gong at home since you could not meet with your group. In XXXX 2022 after group sessions had resumed on XXXX XXXX XXXX, you testified that the police had discovered your group sessions and two (2) days later, you fled to Canada with your wife and child. On XXXX XXXX 2022, you learned from your mother that the police had come to your home in China accusing you of practicing Falun Gong and searched your home for you. On XXXX XXXX 2022, a police summons was issued against you for the same reason. You testified that the only reason you had initially gone back was to take care of your father as he was dying. I found your explanation to be reasonable because the imminent death of your father and final opportunity to say your farewell to him outweighed fear of persecution at the time especially because the Chinese state authorities had not discovered your Falun Gong activities until later.

[8] I also found your delay in leaving China reasonable because as you testified, the delay was caused by pandemic lockdowns which were circumstances outside your control. Therefore, I give these reasons significant weight in explaining your reavailment and delay in leaving. I have thought about these concerns along with the rest of your otherwise credible testimony. I find that the credible evidence you provided outweighs these concerns.

[9] Your claim is supported by your personal documents including identity and marriage documents, documents related to your father’s death, medical documents for your lower back injury, a copy of the police summons, support letters from fellow Falun Gong practitioners in Canada, and photos of your practice of Falun Gong.

[10] After reviewing the documents, I have no reason to doubt their authenticity and therefore place significant weight on them in establishing the key allegations of your claim.

[11] Given that your family members including children, sorry, given that family members including children of Falun Gong practitioners are targeted by state authorities, I find that your wife and child also have a credible fear of persecution through their association with you. Based on the principal claimant’s evidence before me, I find that you have established a subjective fear of persecution meaning that you genuinely fear the Chinese state authorities and the harm they would cause you and your family for practicing Falun Gong which is outlawed in the country and enforced by the state authorities. I find that the credible evidence that goes to the core of your claims outweighs any contrasting evidence.

[12] Your risk is supported by the country conditions evidence. What happened to you in China and what you fear might happen to you if you return to China is supported by the evidence about the country conditions. There are many documents in the National Documentation Package showing authorities’ ill treatment of Falun Gong practitioners in China.

[13] Item 1.10 indicates that Chinese law provides for up to a seven (7) year prison sentence for those engaging in Falun Gong activities.

[14] Item 12.22 indicates that Chinese authorities have pursued sanctions against practitioners since 1999 and that the Chinese government maintains an extrajudicial security apparatus for the purpose of eliminating the Falun Gong movement.

[15] Item 1.10 states that correctional officers pressure Falun Gong practitioners to denounce their practice and that those discovered to be practicing Falun Gong have difficulty finding jobs after release from detention. The same document sate that those discovered to be practicing Falun Gong face ongoing harassment, imprisonment and torture in prison.

[16] Item 12.22 states that authorities use coercion against practitioners and threaten to have the practitioners’ family members dismissed from their jobs or to impede the education or social benefits of practitioners’ children.

[17] An August 2018 report by the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights for the UPR of the human rights situation in China notes that the children of Falun Gong practitioners were arrested, detained, and subjected to ill treatment and torture.

[18] Item 12.22 also indicated that in cases where authorities are pursuing a case against a known Falun Gong practitioner, their family and friends might be subject to harassment as well particularly if charges are brought against the practitioner under its national security laws. I find that the subjective evidence applies to the claimants in this case as the principal claimant is wanted by Chinese authorities as per the police summons and that through association with the principal claimant, the wife and child would also face similar persecution.

[19] After revieing the documentation above, I find the Chinese state authorities’ treatment of Falun Gong practitioners is regular, pervasive, and amounts to persecution. I therefore find that you have established an objective basis for your fears. You are not protected by your state or safe anywhere in China. You have established that if you return to China, you will face a risk from state authorities. In the circumstances of your case, this means that there is no adequate state protection available to you in China because Falun Gong activities are outlawed in the country and the state would be enforcing these laws. As Falun Gong activities are outlawed throughout the country, you would be forced to suppress your religious beliefs and practices. Additionally, your wife and child, the associate claimants, would not have access to state protection due to, due to their association with you as described by the objective evidence of family persecution of Falun Gong practitioners above.

[20] For the same reasons, there is no internal flight alternative because there is nowhere safe for you or your family to go within China because the laws and enforcement are applied equally throughout the country.

[21] Based on all of the evidence above and my analysis, I determine that XXXX XXXX, XXXX XXXX, XXXX XXXX, are Convention refugees and I accept your claims.

 

——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———