2024 RLLR 167

Citation: 2024 RLLR 167
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: November 28, 2024
Panel: Michael Fleming
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Amro Hayek
Country: Jordan
RPD Number: TC3-16204
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A

DECISION

[1]       MEMBER: This is the decision of the Refugee Protection Division for the following claimant, XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX.

[2] CLAIMANT: Yes.

[3] MEMBER: Close enough that you recognized it. The File Number is TC3-16204. You are claiming to be a citizen of Jordan, and you are claiming refugee protection pursuant to section 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.

[4] I have taken the following guidelines into consideration for my decision. Guideline 9, sexual orientation, which deals with sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and sex characteristics.

[5] I have considered your testimony and the other evidence in the case and I am ready to render my decision orally. The written decision will come to you shortly and may be amended to include specific citations to exhibits and case law as needed.

[6] I find that you are a Convention refugee on the grounds of membership in a particular social group, and that is gay or bisexual men.

[7] You have alleged the following. That you fear persecution at the hands of society at large, and the law enforcement agencies of your state, and that this is due to your sexual orientation as a gay or bisexual man. You allege if you return that you face a risk of physical harm at the hands of society in general. You allege that there is no state protection for you, nor is there an internal flight alternative.

[8] Your personal identity as a citizen of Jordan has been established by your testimony and by the supporting documents filed in Exhibit 1. Those documents are, in this instance, your passport.

[9] I find on a balance of probabilities that identity and country of reference have been established.
[10] I find that there is a link between what you fear and one of the five (5) Convention grounds, namely membership in a particular social group, that is being a gay or bisexual man. I have therefore assessed the claim under section 96.

[11] You allege the following about experiences giving rise to the claim. You testified that you understood your sexual orientation from about the age 21. You identify not with a label but as a person who is attracted sexually to both men and women. You understood the consequences of being identified as gay or bisexual in the conservative society of your country.

[12] You engaged in one long-term relationship that began while you were an adult and while you were working. That relationship was with a co-worker. That relationship began known to your family, and it resulted in you being threatened by your family and by the family of your intimate partner, and also in being subjected to religious teachings in order to convert your orientation.

[13] According to Maldonado, when a claimant swears to certain facts being true, this creates a presumption that they are, unless there is a valid reason to doubt the truthfulness.

[14] I find that you are a credible and sincere witness in relation to the core allegations of your claim, and I believe what you have told me today in your testimony.

[15] You have also testified to your understanding of the social attitudes towards gay people in Jordan. You testified as to a need to hide your true self in order to avoid sanction. And you testified to the existence of a relationship with A.J., a relationship that once exposed resulted in harm to you and sanction in the form of attempted conversion through religion.

[16] Your testimony was straightforward. You answered promptly and without undue hesitation. Your testimony was consistent with the information in your Basis of Claim. There were no significant discrepancies, omissions, or inconsistencies in your evidence.

[17] You provided some documents that you suggest corroborate your claim. A letter from the 519 organization, and some photographs taken at nightclubs in the village.

[18] I give these documents no weight in assessing your claim, because these are items that are readily available to any member of the public who chooses to join XXXX, which is an inclusive organization, or to attend the clubs in XXXX XXXX.

[19] In terms of your general credibility, I have found you to be a credible witness, and I therefore accept what you have alleged in your oral testimony and your Basis of Claim form. I find that on a balance of probabilities you have established that you are a bisexual man, and therefore, a member of that particular social group.

[20] Your subjective fear is established by your credible testimony.

[21] I also find that your claim is objectively well-founded. I will refer to the NDP for Jordan, the 2024 version. Specifically, tab 2.1, which is the United States Department of State report for 2023, which reports on significant human rights issues, including credible reports of crimes involving violence or threats of violence targeting lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, or intersex persons. They have reported that security services arbitrarily arrested, intimidated, and harassed lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersex individuals.

[22] Consensual same-sex sexual conduct, while not being criminalized, has sometimes resulted in the arrest of [2SLGBTQI+] individuals arbitrarily or on the pretext of involving violating public order, morality laws, or public decency ordnances.

[23] These points are consistent with the experience that you as the claimant have testified to. In sum, I find that you have established a well-founded fear of persecution.

[24] In this case, the state is one of the agents of persecution. I am quoting again from the DOS report. Parents were customarily allowed to request informal warrants from security services for children, including adult children, to suspend their movements inside the country, to prevent travel abroad, or to require authorities to forcibly return them to family custody, even if the family members had previously threatened that person’s life. There is little to no official action to investigate, prosecute, or punish those complicit in violence or abuses against the LGBTQI persons by state or non-state actors.

[25] Therefore, I find that if you were returned, you face risk from state authorities. Accordingly, I find there is no state protection available to you.

[26] Likewise, since the state is in control of its territories, I find that there is no internal flight alternative available to you.

[27] Based on the totality of the evidence and my analysis above, I find that you are a Convention refugee, and I have accepted your claim.

 

——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———