2024 RLLR 153

Citation: 2024 RLLR 153
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: January 23, 2024
Panel: J. Eberhard
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Felix Chakirov
Country: India
RPD Number: TC0-08464
Associated RPD Number(s): TC0-08469, TC0-08470, TC0-08471
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A

DECISION

[1]       MEMBER: This is the formal of decision of claim file TC0-08464 (inaudible) on the 22nd of January 2024. Because of a substantial amount of personal and country condition disclosure that was not before me, we had to resume the following day, 23 January 2024. At the end of the hearing I provided the claimants with an overview of their positive decision, and this is the formal rendering of the decision.

[2] The decision will be made available to the claimants in the form of an unedited transcript, which they will receive in the mail in the near future and their counsel will also get a copy without delay by email.

[3] The claims, XXXX XXXX XXXX, who is the principal claimant, his wife, XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX, who is the associate claimant, and their two (2) sons, XXXX XXXX and XXXX XXXX, who is the minor claimant, claim to be citizens of India and are claiming refugee protection pursuant to sections 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration Refugee Protection Act.

[4] The principal claimant served as designated representative for the minor claimant. I find that you are Convention refugees because you have established that you face a serious possibility of persecution in India if you return on the basis of three (3) intersecting convention grounds, namely, real and imputed political opinion, religion, and family membership in a particular social group as persons facing gender-based targeting by state actors and family members respectively.

[5] In hearing and deciding your claims I have considered and applied the Chairperson’s Guidelines on Gender Considerations in Proceedings before the Board and Guidelines on Child Refugee Claimants in relation to the minor claimant’s claim. These are Guidelines 4 and 3, respectively.

[6] Your Basis of Claim forms, which you signed on the 15th of June 2020, and updated by amendments submitted on 12 January 2022, you allege fearing persecution by multiple agents of persecution in India if you return. Specifically, as Muslims, members of the religious minority group who were living abroad and financially supporting your mosque in India, you fear ongoing religious, political, and gender-based persecution, including by Hindu extremists such as members of the ruling BJP Party and the RSS in relation.

[7] As family members you also fear ongoing persecution by the principal claimant’s father, who has demonstrated his ability to use his political connections to harm you, especially into the inquest of his XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX in 2012, following years of XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX. His treatment of her is not unlike his mistreatment of the principal claimant while he was growing up, and it was also similar to his mistreatment and abuse of the associate claimant while she resided with the father-in-law after the principal claimant and associate claimant married in 2004. You allege that the father-in-law beat your children while they were in the family’s home.

[8] The painful details of your claim are well known to you and I will not repeat them at length here, including out of respect for you. As noted, you married in 2004 and your first son was born in 2005. The minor claimant was born in 2009. After your marriage you resided together in India with the principal claimant’s father who became the associate claimant’s father-in-law, and with other family members, including a stepmother and the principal claimant’s brothers and their wives and children.

[9] The principal claimant has primarily lived and worked since 2009 in Saudi Arabia and after moving your family to your own home in India in 2009, in 2014 your wife and sons joined you in Saudi Arabia. Like your brother, I’m addressing the principal claimant, you moved you family out of your father’s home because within it they faced serious mistreatment including beatings by your father and later abuse by his third wife. The main contentious point was comparative doweries paid and the possibility for the principal claimant’s father of additional enrichment.

[10] Your, the principal claimant’s, father wanted more dowery money and he taunted and abused your brother’s wife, his daughter-in-law, even telling her to leave her husband, so that he could marry someone else and gain more money that way, XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX Again, the purpose was remarriage that would generate more wealth. On XXXX XXXX 2012, in the face of this XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX. Because you, the associate claimant, had been her close confidant, even when she was living outside of the home, you considered her like a sister, to use your own words, and you had lived in the home and XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXXyou agreed to be a witness at the inquest of your sister-in-law’s death. You don’t know the outcome of the inquest, but when you last knew it was ongoing. There is presently no contact between the principal claimant and his father or even his brothers.

[11] In this context, when the Indian authorities later searched to locate your family inside India, after they returned from Saudi Arabia, first temporarily and the permanently, the principal claimant’s father disclosed your location. You believe he did this leading to your endangerment by authorities who by then had come to believe that you, the principal claimant, were involved in Islamic extremism. Authorities accused you of terrorism because you were raising and donating funds to support your mosque and the members of your community in Kerala while you were still living in Saudi Arabia. In fact, you were engaged in these activities to fulfil your long held desire to support members of your community who had difficulty obtaining and accessing education and medical care, including because of ongoing discrimination, harassment, and even violence against Muslims in India. In addition, you wanted these community members to have opportunities that you were not able to enjoy.

[12] In particular, from Saudi Arabia you sent regular donations to the mosque and in Saudi Arabia you also organized other community members, including co-workers from the same part of India, pooling together their funds as well. On XXXX XXXX 2018, you, the principal claimant, were overheard in related conversations by two Hindu members of your community in Kerala. They were co-workers of yours in Saudi Arabia. They reported what they heard to local Indian authorities, namely that you were involved in anti-government terrorist activities from Saudi Arabia through the financial support of your mosque. When you, the associate claimant, returned to India in XXXX 2018, Hindu extremists attacked you, together with your parents, at your family’s home. You were all admitted and treated in hospital for XXXX days for the injuries you received, and you didn’t report the matter to police because you feared the state authorities who were involved.

[13] In XXXX 2018, the principal claimant returned to India to care for the associate claimants, his in-laws, who were left there alone because all of their kids by then had left India, including to seek protection in Brazil. On XXXX XXXX 2018, a local leader of BJP, the ruling party, was personally involved in abducting, threatening, physically attacking, and extorting you, the principal claimant. He sent three (3) RSS persons to your home and abducted you into a van, which took you to a big house which you recognized as XXXX XXXX. A BJP leader was present, and you recognized him from having seen him on the news, and he was there together with about 14 other people. These men violated your dignity as a human being, and as a Muslim person by their mistreatment and beating of you and by the nature of the demands they made.

[14] After your interrogation, you were released on a promise to make a “mandatory donation” of XXXX XXXX to them, Hindus, within a week. You agreed and when they came to collect the money you said you needed a few more days. In fact, you fled back to Saudi Arabia before the payment could be collected,

[15] Foreigners, despite your long residency and work experience in Saudi Arabia, you could no longer remain, having no rights to permanently reside or become citizens there. The associate claimant and your children were only there as your dependents and retuned to India in XXXX 2019. The principal claimant returned in XXXX 2019 having been given notice that he would no longer have employment sponsorship in early 2019, in XXXX or XXXX.

[16] Within a short time of returning to India, despite your practice of staying in different places that you rented from friends or when you stayed with friends that were away from your own home in India, police located you. On the XXXX XXXX XXXX 2019, under the guise of asking you questions about the XXXX XXXX XXXX inquest the police set you both up, taking you, the principal claimant and associate claimant, into custody. They interrogated, mistreated, and beat you, accusing you of being Islamic extremists involved in terrorism against India. They threatened to kill you and only released you when you agreed to pay a hefty bribe of XXXX XXXXor approximately XXXX XXXX XXXX dollars Canadian. You called your cousin for help and he was able to make the arrangements for you on your behalf.

[17] You previously had begun to put into place visas in case you needed to travel internationally for your safety. These were issued in XXXX and XXXX 2018. You were therefore able to flee India for Canada without delay after you were released from authorities’ custody and purchased your flights. You claimed protection on your arrival into Canada at the airport on the XXXX XXXX XXXX 2019. And since you have been gone authorities have repeatedly visited your family members in India seeking to know our whereabouts and threatening you for your support of your religious community and its members.

[18] In Canada your family members have continued outreach efforts, including by supporting not only your community in India, but also through volunteer work here by the principal and eldest child of the family, through our contributions to several community organizations here in the Toronto area.

[19] You have established your identities as nationals of India on a balance of probabilities through your testimony and the supporting documents that you provided, specifically copies of your passports issued by India. Copies are available in Exhibits 1 and 4. Your passports also contain visas for Canada for each of you respectively, and they were issued between XXXX and XXXX 2018. Your passports also contain your residency permits for Saudi Arabia, specifying the dependent permits in the associate and younger claimants’ cases and limited work permission in the case of the principal claimant.

[20] The country condition documents for Saudi Arabia in section 3 of the National Documentation Package clearly indicates that foreign nationals are not entitled to citizenship in Saudi Arabia and are permitted to work in the country only on a limited basis and within a sponsorship system. If a foreign worker loses employment sponsorship, he and any dependents must leave the country within a specified time.

[21] You’ve testified about having been provided notice of the end of your contract in XXXX or XXXX 2019 by your longtime employer in Saudi Arabia. There you had served as a XXXX and XXXX, and your contract would not be renewed. You understood the cause was limitations on foreign workers and the practice of replacing at regular intervals more senior foreign workers with less senior ones who were also less expensive.

[22] According to the information in the NDP for Saudi Arabia, particularly again in the citizen section at Item 3.1, and in related documents, despite your long residency in the country you are not citizens and you are not entitled to access citizenship in Saudi Arabia or to otherwise enjoy the rights or benefits of Saudi citizens for whom employers reserve the best employment positions, including in government.

[23] I find you all to be very credible witnesses and I believe what you have alleged in support of your claim. I have heard from three (3) members of your family and, through the principal claimant, from the minor claimant. You testified clearly and at times with emotion, but consistently and without hesitation. You naturally and spontaneously answered my wide ranging questions about the central issues in your claims and your answers were direct and responsive. There were no material inconsistencies in your testimony or contradictions between it and the other evidence before me that you didn’t satisfactorily explain.

[24] In particular, I accept your explanation for why you had to return to India from Saudi Arabia to care for the associate claimant’s ailing parents in 2018. Until the associate and minor claimants had first returned to India in XXXX 2018 your family members had not been targeted in India, by the principal claimant’s father in relation to the inquest, or by state actors following the disclosure on XXXX XXXX 2018 to Hindu worker colleagues in Saudi, the principal claimant’s fundraising and contributions to the local mosque in Kerala. Your ability to return to India from Saudi Arabia dramatically deteriorated after these incidents that led to your active targeting and accusations against you of Islamic extremism.

[25] To corroborate your claim, in addition to your testimony and additional personal identification documents, you presented several documents that directly address the fundamental issue in your claims. Letters and receipts from your local mosque in Kerala corroborate your account of your longstanding financial support, including of medical and educational programs for community members and children without parents. Your ongoing involvement in your religious community as a valued member of the community is also supported by documents before me in the same exhibit, number 5.

[26] These aspects of your personal identity are also substantiated by the many letters written on your behalf in Canada, which show your ongoing community-based volunteer and support work, including in your religious community here. Your eldest son is similarly engaged and has logged more than 500 hours of community service, also becoming a valued contributor to helping community-based organizations in Canada, both within the church community and also more broadly than that. Organizations like the XXXX XXXX, for example.

[27] Your employment letters and financial statements are also consistent with those provided alongside letters written on your behalf by your former colleagues in Saudi Arabia. I’m speaking to the principal claimant here. These letters corroborate your account of having been overhead and challenged about your fundraising and support of your Kerala mosque while you were in Saudi Arabia in your workplace, which is what you believe led to your targeting by state actors when you returned to India. The persons that overheard you were also Hindu and supporters of the BJP.

[28] The documentary evidence you presented was not only substantial, at nearly 400 pages, but also detailed and directly reflective of the elements of your claims. The authors of many of the letters you provided gave insights and direct knowledge, witness accounts, of the key incidents that led to your targeting, in particular ways and by particular actors in 2018 and 2019 in India when you and your family returned, despite your efforts to stay outside of your own home in order to protect yourselves.

[29] You believe that the principal claimant’s father was involved in disclosing your location to BJP authorities. At the time the principal claimant returned to India in 2018 the inquest of the XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX was ongoing. The entire first half of your main disclosure package is a collection of the related inquest materials, including 27 or more witness statements that attest to her XXXX by your father, or father-in-law, as appropriate. All of this information is consistent with your accounts. Most notably, when read alongside your statement, speaking to the associate claimant, is witness number 9. You testified that you felt you had to bear witness to her experience in life because XXXX XXXX XXXX you were her voice. XXXX XXXX XXXXcertificate is among the related documents before me, together with police documents, including the XXXXJuly 2012 final report, the grant of bail, and date of release, as well as the inquest report.

[30] Among the witnesses, your sister-in-law’s parents are listed and their statements, as well as others, confirm your account of being among the daughters-in-law who similarly faced abuse and beatings by the principal claimant’s father, your father-in-law, along with your children, while you were living in the home and even later. Among the most startling statements in the reports is evidence that he even beat his grandchild when the baby was just XXXX XXXX. Your sister-in-law was also locked in her room and prohibited from leaving and she tried to spare her husband by telling him little of what was happening. Fortunately, yours is a different relationship and the principal claimant relocated your family first within India in 2009 and later to Saudi Arabia in 2014 in order to save you and protect you from abuse. And when I say “you”, I mean both the associate claimant, your children, and even the principal claimant, who had suffered abuse as well.

[31] Other friends in India have written on your behalf, including the person with whom your family stayed in India from XXXX until XXXX 2019 when you left. Your cousin who paid the bribe for your release together from authorities on XXXX XXXX, 2019 has also written a letter on your behalf containing related details. Medical documents are also in evidence, including those that provide information consistent with your accounts of the physical and emotional injuries you’ve suffered, together with other family members, including the associate claimant’s parents. Reports detail XXXX XXXX XXXX injuries for the principal claimant, and your family believes many of the other psychological and emotional weights of all that you have been through have caused some of the health effects including XXXX and XXXX, as well as XXXX, that you continue to experience.

[32] You also have provided documents that relate these effects to the loss on the XXXX XXXX XXXX 2023 of the son you were expecting together. The child is named for the principal claimant and related documents including the funeral notice confirm this deeply painful loss for your family. Psychological reports also contained consistent information.

[33] The associate claimant’s family is now safe living outside of India in the UK, with the associate claimant’s brother. The other brother is also safe living in Australia. The principal claimant has no further contact with his father or brothers following the family’s difficult history. Other ancillary but nonetheless important documents include a copy of the principal claimant’s father’s political membership card, which corroborates the fact that even though he was a XXXX by profession, he was politically active and therefore remains influential, including because of the number ofXXXX XXXX XXXX XXXXover the years locally.

[34] There are also medical certificates and a letter from a life-long friend that confirms that the principal claimant’s father is still looking for the associate claimant. A recent WhatsApp exchange by the principal claimant seeks an update of information about the inquest and case against his father. No additional information was forthcoming.

[35] Having carefully considered the totality of the evidence before me, I find the information you have presented in your testimony and personal documents is credible.

[36] Persons who seek refugee protection as Convention refugees have to establish what we call a well-founded fear of persecution on Convention grounds. There are two (2) parts to this. Claimants have to show both that they are subjectively afraid of persecution and that there are good reasons for their fear on an objective basis, including by review of the country condition documents about what actually is happening on the ground in India in your case.

[37] As noted in your case, the Convention grounds are multiple and intersecting and include religion, because you are Muslims, which is a minority religion in India. It is also based on your real and perceived political opinion, because you have actively supported and maintained your involvement in your mosque in India, including financially, even while living in Saudi Arabia. The risk of persecution that you face is also based on your membership in a particular social group of women and men and family members, respectively, given your mistreatment, in the principal claimant’s case by BJP, state authorities and their associates, as a man; and in the associate claimant’s case, given the gender-based abuse and ongoing threats by your father-in-law. Given the history of extended family abuse by the principal claimant’s father against both him and your children, you are membership in a particular social group as an extended family. And given his political influence, the principal claimant’s father’s involvement or hand in political targeting by state actors is an additional complexity and intersecting risk for all of you.

[38] In this context I find your actions are consistent with those of persons who subjectively fear persecution, including being killed, if you return to India. In making this finding I have considered your decision to hide when you returned to India from Saudi Arabia, both briefly during your visits in 2018 and later when the principal claimant lost his employment sponsorship in Saudi Arabia and therefore had to return to India with your family all together. You finally fled the country because of the ongoing and increasing risk to your physical safety and lives, given your ongoing targeting by state authorities and the principal claimant’s father.

[39] I also find that the country condition documents contain information that is consistent with your allegations that there is a serious possibility of persecution if you return to India. In particular, I looked at a number of documents in the most recent National Documentation Package for India, dated 30 November 2023, as well as the country condition documents that Counsel provided in Exhibit 10.

[40] In particular, I note Items 2.1, 12.14, 12.15, 12.20, and 12.19. These are reports by the Human Rights Watch, by the U.S. Committee on International Religious Freedom, by the United Kingdom Home Office, and one is a Response to Information Request, IND200257.e, which is dated 18 June 2020. By way of context for the background of religious and political components of your claim I note the documentary evidence indicates that Hindus constitute 79.8 percent of the Indian population, Muslims 14.2 percent, Christians 2.3 percent, and Sikhs 1.7 percent. Christians are recognized under the 1992 National Commission for Minorities as one (1) of five (5) officially acknowledged minority communities. Institution and the laws of India generally speaking protect religious freedom.

[41] Nevertheless, other sources report that religious chauvinism has increased in recent years. A fundamentalist Hindu group causes concerns and is called the RSS for short, Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. The RSS is known to “insight and perpetrate violence against Muslim and Christian minorities as their main intention is to have one nation with one religion, Hinduism.” Sources further indicate that the BJP party is seen as the political wing of the RSS nationalist Hindu movement.

[42] I also note several articles, especially in Section 5 of the National Documentation Package for India related to the treatment of women, including violence at home, and even outside the home. I note two (2) information on child abuse within families, which is consistent with the principal claimant’s experience of growing up with his father and your entire family’s experience of living within the extended family home environment with the principal claimant’s father until 2009. The environment was so severe, again, it led to your XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX XXXX.

[43] The United States Department of State Report states the following. Significant human rights issues in India include credible reports of unlawful and arbitrary killings, including extrajudicial killings by the government or its agents, torture, or cruel and unusual or degrading treatment or punishment by police or prison officials, arbitrary arrest and detention, arbitrary or unlawful interference with privacy, and there is serious government corruption with lack of investigation of and accountability for (inaudible) including domestic and partner and violence, sexual violence, workplace violence, child early and forced marriage, femicide, another term for honour killings, and other forms of violence. Crimes involving violence or threats of violence targeting members of national, racial, ethnic and minority groups, based on religious affiliation are also reported. There were reports, too, that the government or its agents committed arbitrary or unlawful killings and, again, extrajudicial killings of suspected criminals and terrorists.

[44] I note that you have been accused by state authorities involved with BJP as involved in Islamic extremism or otherwise terrorism, as recognized in India. There is an example of this in the United States Department of State Report which states, “On May 20 media appointed a panel of three (3) independent investigators appointed by the Supreme Court who recommended criminal charges, including homicide against 10 Telangana police officers. The police officers were allegedly involved in “encounter killings” of four (4) suspects in the 2019 rape and murder of a woman. An encounter death is a term to describe any death that occurs because of an encounter between security or police forces and alleged criminals or insurgents.”

[45] I also note in the United States Department of State Report information about the role that doweries continue to play in India, despite the fact that they are not supposed to be part of a marriage contract. Under the heading of “Other forms of gender-based violence” this report states the following at page 35, “The law forbids the acceptance of marriage doweries, but many families continue to offer and accept doweries and dowery disputes remain a serious problem. Data shows a total of 6,753 dowery-related deaths in the year 2021 compared to 7,045 in 2020. The highest number of cases was registered in one particular state with 22,035 victims [this is not your state] and most states employ dowery prohibition officers. A 2010 Supreme Court ruling mandates all trial courts to charge defendants in dowery death cases with murder.”

[46] In respect of the involvement of in-laws and pressure that in-laws can bring to bear, I also note the following example which states, “On July 28th a newly married woman, aged 21, was allegedly forced by her husband and in-laws to drink acid at a certain place, she died in hospital on August 3. The woman’s family members allege that she was being tortured by her husband and in-laws as the family couldn’t pay a dowery or gift, a motorcycle, upon her marriage. The police later arrested her husband.”

[47] I’m just going to make a couple of other notes in respect of some of the other most salient country condition reports. The United States Commission on International Religious Freedom, which is Item 12.20, consistently notes that the population of Muslims in India is 14.2 percent and that Article 25 of the Constitution grants all individuals freedom of conscience, including the right to practice, profess, and propagate religion. The Indian government has been led, since 2014, by the BJP. The BJP-led government and leaders are at the national state and local level and have advocated, instituted, and enforced sectarian policies seeking to establish India as an overly Hindu state, contrary to India’s secular foundation and at grave danger to India’s religious minorities. The RSS, an organization closely affiliated with Prime Minister Modi’s BJP government, aggressively advocates for a pure Hindu state. The RSS is considered to be a paramilitary force.

[48] Over the past two (2) years the Indian government has reportedly suspended the funding of several Christian and Islamic organizations under a new Act, due to alleged conversion activity. In June 2021 the operations of the Initiative, an NGO in New Delhi, reporting on the arbitrary use of laws and security force on ethnic and religious minorities in northeast Indian states was suspended under this Act, and in April 2022 the government cancelled the organization’s lease.

[49] Government officials and nonstate actors continue to use social media platforms and other forms of communication to intimidate and spread hatred and disinformation against minority communities, and religious minorities continue to face targeted violence and discrimination for being perceived as a threat to Hinduism. Authorities, including police at times assist Hindu nationalist vigilante groups and a certain organization has received credible reports that adherence of these hardline groups threaten and use violence, including sexual assault, to punish and subdue religions minorities, including Dalits, Christians, and Muslims, who are often discriminated against, both for converting and for being lower caste.

[50] The Human Rights Watch Report notes that BJP authorities have demolished Muslim homes and properties without legal authorization and have publicly flogged Muslim men accused of disrupting a Hindu festival. Authorities in several Indian states are carrying out violence against Muslims as a kind of summary punishment, according to the Asia Director of Human Rights Watch. Officials blatantly disregard the rule of law and they are sending a message to the public that Muslims can be discriminated against and attacked.

[51] A police officer in civilian clothing wearing a gun holster was filmed publicly flogging several Muslim men with sticks while other officials held the men against an electricity pole. In a video shown and even praised on some pro-government television news networks, several uniformed police officers watched he flogging and the strikes against the accused with sticks, while a crowd of men and women cheer and applaud. The police ordered an inquiry only following social media criticism of the video recordings.

[52] A United Nations Special Rapporteur wrote to the Indian government to express concern that “some of the evictions have been carried out as a form of collective and arbitrary punishment against the Muslim minority and low-income community for alleged participation in intercommunal violence, while authorities reportedly failed to investigate these incidents, including incitement to violence and acts of intimidation that contributed to the outbreak of violence.”

[53] Having considered the totality of evidence before me, including personal documentation and other evidence, together with the objective documentation, I find there is a serious possibility you will face persecution if you return to India. You have established a well-founded fear of persecution if you return.

[54] States are presumed to be capable of protecting their own citizens, except when a state is in complete breakdown. The presumption of state protection can be rebutted by sufficient clear and convincing evidence of the absence of adequate state protection. According to the objective evidence before me about the availability of state protection from persecution for Muslims in India, I note “the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom placed India on its watch list in 2009, citing its failure to adequately protect religious minorities and a growing culture of impunity for those who commit religious attacks.”

[55] Taking into account all of the objective evidence that I have just reviewed, including the involvement of state actors in discrimination against and persecution of Muslims in India in certain circumstances, I am following the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision of Ward in relying on your own personal experiences of interfamily violence, including gender-based violence, as well as persecution by state actors, specifically BJP and RSS associates and members, including on political grounds. I also rely on the objective reports of the situations facing others similarly situated to you, including examples that I have provided, as persons who are targeted by the same political actors, officials, state, and militants together. I note the experience of your sister-in-law and lack of final justice in her XXXX, despite the inquest and charges against the principal claimant’s father.

[56] I find that these personal experiences of your own and of others similarly situated to you who are Muslim, who are perceived to be involved in extremism or terrorists simply because they participate and support their community, and of persons who have experienced gender-based violence both within a family context and by state actors, all constitutes clear and convincing evidence that rebuts the presumption that adequate state protection is available to you in India if you return and seek it. I therefore find on a balance of probabilities state authorities cannot or will not adequately protect you and state protection is not available to you if you return to India.

[57] Given the size of India alone, an Internal Flight Alternative is often possible, even for claimants who have credibly established they face persecution in their home community or elsewhere in the country. I have carefully assessed your situation including the multiple intersecting grounds on which you face persecution and the ways in which these reinforce and complicate your vulnerability to mistreatment and serious harm, including death, that cumulatively rises to the level of persecution. Given the mixed personal and political environments, and your father’s longstanding willingness and ability to seek and harm you directly or indirectly, for the foregoing reasons I find you established you face a serious possibility of persecution throughout the country and I therefore find that there is no viable Internal Flight Alternative available to you.

[58] Taking into account the totality of evidence before me, I therefore find that you are Convention refugees and I accept your claims.

 

——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———