2024 RLLR 162
Citation:
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: February 2, 2024
Panel: W. Chin
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Nicholas Woodward
Country: Barbados
RPD Number: TC2-00618
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A
REASONS FOR DECISION
INTRODUCTION
[1] This is a decision in respect of the claimant XXXX XXXX XXXX, who claims to be a citizen of Barbados and is claiming refugee protection pursuant to sections 96 and 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA).[1]
ALLEGATIONS
[2] The claimant’s full allegations are set out in her Basis of Claim (BOC) form and related narrative.[2] In summary, the claimant alleges that she fears persecution or harm at the hands of the Barbadian state, and the general community, on account of her sexual orientation as a lesbian.
DETERMINATION
[3] I find the claimant has established a serious possibility of persecution on a Convention ground. The claimant is a Convention refugee.
ANALYSIS
Identity
[4] I find the claimant has established her identity as a national of Barbados, on a balance of probabilities, based on the copy of her passport.[3]
Credibility
[5] There are no relevant inconsistencies in the claimant’s narrative, or her other evidence before me. There are no contradictions or inconsistencies in the documentation that she provided which would give sufficient reason to doubt her evidence.
[6] In support of the claim, the claimant disclosed a registrar certificate,[4] from the Supreme Court, in Barbados, in respect of proof of a legal name change from XXXX to “XXXX”. She also provided several letters[5] of support from long-time friends, workplace colleagues, and her grandmother, which conform to the claimant’s allegations. Also provided are photographs of the claimant’s various attendances at Canadian Pride, and “Blockobana”, a celebration for black pride weekend.
[7] I have no reason to doubt the authenticity of this evidence, and I assign it full weight. I find that the claimant has established with credible and trustworthy evidence her sexual orientation as a lesbian, and I therefore find the claimant has established her subjective fear, on a balance of probabilities.
Well-Founded Fear of Persecution
[8] I also find that the objective country condition evidence supports the claimant’s allegations. The objective evidence indicates that LGBTQ persons face harassment and persecutory discrimination in several aspects of daily life with major socioeconomic consequences in Barbados.
[9] The evidence before me is that homosexual acts are illegal in Barbados. The Sexual Offences Act states the following:
Section 9. Buggery. Any person who commits buggery is guilty of an offence and is liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for life.
Section 12. Serious indecency. (1) A person who commits an act of serious indecency on or towards another or incites another to commit that act with the person or with another person is guilty of an offence and, if committed on or towards a person 16 years of age or more or if the person incited is of 16 years of age or more, is liable on conviction to imprisonment for a term of 10 years. (2) A person who commits an act of serious indecency with or towards a child under the age of 16 or incites the child under that age to such an act with him or another, is guilty of an offence and is liable on conviction to imprisonment for a term of 15 years. (3) An act of “serious indecency” is an act, whether natural or unnatural by a person involving the use of the genital organs for the purpose of arousing or gratifying sexual desire.[6]
[10] A Response to Information Request, by the IRB indicates that although the legislation banning homosexual acts is rarely enforced, discrimination against LGBTQ individuals is one of the most serious human rights problems in Barbados, and those guilty of homosexual acts can face a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.[7] Stigma and societal discrimination are often manifested in the form of property damage, ostracism and verbal abuse, unjustified denial of employment, denial of housing, rejection and abandonment by family, friends, and society at large. Furthermore, there are reported incidences of arson, rape, attempted suicide, homelessness, verbal abuse, depression, and assault.[8]
[11] The objective evidence is consistent with the claimant’s evidence, in respect of her stated fears of returning to Barbados, and I find that her subjective fears have an objective basis.
State Protection
[12] The claimant’s agent of persecution is the state, and the general society. The objective evidence indicates that there are no legal protections for those who face discrimination because of their sexual orientation and most members of the LGBTQ community do not report matters to the police for fear of negative repercussions or ridicule. The police in Barbados have been “denounced as discriminatory” in their treatment of victims who are LGBTQ.[9]
[13] Given the objective evidence noted above, I find it objectively unreasonable for the claimant to seek further protection, and the police’s discriminatory and inadequate response demonstrates that state protection could not be seen as reasonably forthcoming.[10] I find the presumption of state protection is rebutted in this case.
Internal Flight Alternative
[14] Given that the claimant’s agent of persecution is the state, the general society of Barbados, and given the objective evidence indicating its discriminatory laws are in effect throughout its territory; I find that the claimant has established on a balance of probabilities, that she would not be safe throughout Barbados if she were forced to return. I find that the claimant’s IFA analysis fails at the first prong of the test.[11] Therefore, an IFA is not available to this claimant, as she would face a serious possibility of persecution throughout Barbados, even if she were to relocate.
CONCLUSION
[15] The claimant is Convention Refugee pursuant to Section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. The claim is accepted.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
[1] Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, S.C. 2001, c. 27 as amended, sections 96 and 97(1).
[2] Exhibit 2, Basis of Claim Form (BOC), TC2‑06032.
[3] Exhibit 1.
[4] Exhibit 5, page 5.
[5] Exhibit 5, pages 9-28.
[6] Exhibit 3, National Documentation Package (NDP), Barbados, November 30, 2023, tab 6.2: Barbados. State-Sponsored Homophobia 2019. International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Association. Lucas Ramón Mendos. March 2019, at page 400.
[7] Exhibit 3, NDP, tab 6.1:Treatment of sexual minorities, including legislation, state protection and support services; social attitudes towards bisexuality (2013-November 2015). Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada. 3 December 2015. BRB105353.E.
[8] Ibid.
[9] Ibid.
[10] Canada (Attorney General) v Ward, [1993], 2 S.C.R. 689.
[11] Rasaratnam v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1992] 1 F.C. 706 (C.A.).
