2024 RLLR 170
Citation: 2024 RLLR 170
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: October 22, 2024
Panel: Ryan Krueger
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Nicholas Woodward
Country: Venezuela
RPD Number: TC3-29884
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-01314
ATIP Pages: N/A
DECISION
[1] MEMBER:
INTRODUCTION
[2] This is the oral decision for the claimant, who is a citizen of Venezuela and who is claiming refugee protection pursuant to section 96 and subsection 97(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.
[3] The Panel has considered the Chairperson’s Guideline 9, “Proceedings Before the IRB Involving Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity and Expression, and Sex Characteristics” in this decision.
ALLEGATIONS
[4] The specifics of this case are set out in the narrative portion of the claimant’s Basis of Claim BOC form in Exhibit 2.
[5] In short, the claimant alleges that he fears persecution in Venezuela on the basis of his sexual orientation as a gay man. He also alleges that he fears persecution at the hands of the Maduro regime, due to his membership and activities with the Un Nuevo Tiempo opposition political party.
DETERMINATION
[6] The Panel finds that the claimant is a Convention refugee.
ANALYSIS
Identity
[7] The claimant has established his identity as a national of Venezuela on a balance of probabilities by his testimony and the supporting documentation filed, namely a copy of his national identification card and birth certificate found in Exhibit 5.
Nexus
[8] The Panel finds that the claimant has established multiple nexuses to the grounds of political opinion, as well as particular social group, as their fear of persecution is also related to their gay sexual orientation. This claim will therefore be assessed pursuant to section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act.
Credibility and Subjective Fear
[9] The claimant testified in a straightforward manner that was predominantly consistent with all the other documents on file, including his BOC form and narrative, and he was able to generally answer all the Panel’s questions and predominantly provided all details that were requested of him.
[10] There were no relevant inconsistencies in his testimony or contradictions between his testimony and the other evidence before the Panel. As a result, the Panel has no reason to doubt the genuineness of the documents on file and assigns them full weight and accordingly finds that the claimant is a credible witness overall.
[11] The claimant gave testimony about his gay sexual orientation, and when he began feeling different, as well as his experience of feeling different. The claimant testified that he began feeling different when he was very young, and that since he can remember, he has been attracted to boys and not girls. He testified that at this time in his life, he used to play with dolls, and that he later informed his parents of his gay sexual orientation at the age of 17.
[12] Moreover, the claimant further testified in detail about a series of same-sex partners that he had in Venezuela and Colombia. He testified about a same-sex classmate named XXXX (ph), who he had a hidden relationship with.
[13] The claimant further testified at length about a relationship he had with a same-sex individual named XXXX (ph) during the claimant’s temporary residence in Colombia. He testified that during his time in Colombia, he participated in an LGBTQI+ community that advocated for LGBTQI+ individuals.
[14] The claimant also testified that he has not had any serious same-sex relationships since his arrival in Canada. Furthermore, the claimant testified that since his arrival in Canada, he feels completed and protected, and that he also feels free and happy to express his sexual orientation.
[15] The Panel notes that the claimant’s testimony concerning his gay sexual orientation is corroborated by dating application screenshots, a letter of support from a friend, as well as a letter of support from an LGBTQI+ organization in Colombia, all found in Exhibit 5.
[16] Moreover, the claimant gave testimony about his anti-regime political opinion and support for the Un Nuevo Tiempo opposition political party. He testified that he became a member of the party at the age of majority and supported the party by organizing the youth and by organizing games and peaceful marches.
[17] Furthermore, the claimant testified that he does not support the current Venezuelan regime because it is against the people and that the claimant also has no rights under the government as a gay man. He also testified that since his arrival in Canada, he has attended peaceful political demonstrations following the Venezuelan election.
[18] The claimant’s testimony concerning his anti-regime political opinion is corroborated by a letter of support from the Um Nuevo Tiempo opposition political party, a letter of support from a friend in Canada, as well as photographs of the claimant attending a demonstration in Canada, all found in Exhibits 5 and 6.
[19] Furthermore, the claimant testified about the mistreatment he faced in Venezuela on the basis of his gay sexual orientation and anti-regime political opinion. The claimant testified that he was teased and mistreated by family members and schoolmates during his younger years concerning his sexual orientation.
[20] The claimant also testified that he was targeted in Venezuela in XXXX of 2016, due to his sexual orientation, after he was leaving a nightclub and was approached by two (2) men who insulted the claimant and his cousin and beat them up.
[21] He also testified that he was threatened by the authorities in Venezuela due to his participation in a peaceful demonstration in the country. The claimant’s testimony about the instances of mistreatment he faced is corroborated by a letter of support found in Exhibit 5.
Failure to Claim in Colombia, Central America, Mexico, and the United States
[22] Furthermore, the Panel notes that it had concerns about the claimant’s failure to claim refugee protection in Colombia, Central America, Mexico, and the United States prior to arriving in Canada. However, the Panel’s concerns were rectified by the claimant’s testimony.
[23] The claimant testified that he always focused on travelling to Canada, and that it was his goal to claim protection in Canada because he believed it was the safest country, a multicultural society, and accepts every type of person.
[24] Overall, the Panel accepts the claimant’s explanations as reasonable and finds that such behaviour does not show a lack of subjective fear, nor does it undermine the claimant’s overall credibility.
[25] In consideration of the claimant’s allegations of forward-facing risk concerning what the claimant fears will happen to him if he returns to Venezuela, the claimant testified that if he returns, he believes that it is probable that he will lose his life.
[26] The Panel finds that the claimant has established his allegations of risk on a balance of probabilities, and that he has established a subjective fear of persecution in Venezuela through his testimony and all the other documents on file.
Objective Basis
[27] The objective evidence supports the claimant’s fear of return to Venezuela because of his political activities against the government and his membership in a particular social group as a gay man.
[28] The Panel finds that the objective evidence supports his subjective fear and establishes a serious possibility of persecution for the claimant if he is forced to return to Venezuela, and the Panel’s reasons are as follows.
[29] Item 2.1 of the National Documentation Package, NDP, details how the illegitimate Maduro regime continues to violate human rights in its attempt to solidify its authority. This includes unlawful or arbitrary killings, forced disappearances, torture by security forces, and arbitrary detentions and crimes, including threats or violence — or threats of violence targeting persons such as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersex persons.
[30] Further at Item 2.14 of the NDP, it notes a deepening political crisis due to tensions between the government and the opposition. This report highlights serious restrictions to freedoms of opinion and expression, peaceful assembly and association, and the right of participation in public affairs. Attacks by pro-government armed civilian groups on political opponents, opponents, demonstrators, and journalists were also documented.
[31] The NDP confirms that the Maduro government is responsible for jailing political opponents and prosecuting civilians in military courts, and that security forces connected to the regime are known to torture detainees and their family members.
[32] Moreover, concerning the claimant’s gay sexual orientation, the objective evidence at NDP 6.1 reports that while same-sex relationships are not criminalized in Venezuela, there are no legal protections for such persons, and they are not protected by anti-discrimination laws.
[33] Many members of the SOGIESC community in Venezuela experience significant societal stigmatization, discrimination and violence, and homophobic attitudes pervade all areas of daily life, including employment, housing, and the provision of social services.
[34] The Panel notes that under the SOGIESC guidelines, being compelled to conceal one’s SOGIESC identity constitutes a serious interference with fundamental human rights, and therefore may amount to persecution if a claimant is expected to conceal their SOGIESC identity as a way to avoid persecution in their country of reference.
[35] Therefore, based on all the evidence before it, the Panel finds that the claimant will face a serious possibility of persecution if forced to return to Venezuela, and his fear is indeed well-founded.
State Protection and Internal Flight Alternative (IFA)
[36] Given that the state is an agent of harm, the Panel finds that adequate state protection is not available to the claimant. In consideration of the evidence, Venezuela will not afford the claimant protection that we expect of a state, and therefore the claimant is consequently unable to obtain adequate protection from their country.
[37] Further, the Panel has also considered whether the claimant has an IFA and has concluded that he does not. As the Venezuelan authorities control the entirety of the country and given the state’s capacity and ongoing interest in arbitrarily detaining those who oppose the government, as well as given the aforementioned treatment of individuals of various SOGIESC backgrounds throughout the country, the Panel finds that the claimant would face a serious possibility of persecution throughout Venezuela, and accordingly finds that there is no IFA available to him.
CONCLUSION
[38] For the foregoing reasons, the Panel finds that the claimant is a Convention refugee pursuant to section 96 of the Act, and therefore accepts his claim.
——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———
