2024 RLLR 59

Citation: 2024 RLLR 59
Tribunal: Refugee Protection Division
Date of Decision: February 19, 2024
Panel: Ramona Muljar
Counsel for the Claimant(s): Teklemichael A Sahlemariam
Country: Ethiopia
RPD Number: VC3-10570
Associated RPD Number(s): N/A
ATIP Number: A-2025-00128
ATIP Pages: N/A

DECISION

[1]       MEMBER: All right, so, for the record, this is the decision of the Refugee Protection Division in the claim of XXXX XXXX XXXX, a citizen of Ethiopia. You, the claimant, allege that you are a citizen of Ethiopia, and you claim to have a fear of persecution at the hands of Ethiopian government forces because of your ethnicity and because of your gender as a woman. In coming to my decision, I considered the testimony that we heard here today, the evidence that you submitted prior to the hearing, as well as the relevant and most recent country condition information available to me. In making my decision, I did also consider and apply the Chairperson’s Guideline 4, which is the “Gender Considerations in Proceedings Before the IRB” guideline.

DETERMINATION

[2] I determine that you meet the definition of a Convention refugee and that you face a serious possibility of persecution in your home country because of a Convention ground. My reasons follow.

ALLEGATIONS

[3] Your allegations were set out in detail in your written Basis of Claim form, and they were confirmed here today in your oral testimony, so I will just summarize those allegations very briefly now. You stated that you are of the Amhara ethnicity and you are from Addis Ababa.

[4] In 2023, you were detained and held XXXX by Ethiopian security forces because you participated in a protest called for by the Ethiopian Orthodox Christian church that you belong to. You were released after signing a document.

[5] You fear being arrested and physically harmed by government forces because of your ethnicity and because you were already detained in Ethiopia. Should you return there, you also fear gender-based violence from security — from the security forces in Ethiopia.

MY FINDINGS

[6] Firstly, your identity — I find that your identity has been established by your consistent testimony as well as by a copy of your national passport and your ID card on file.

Credibility

[7] There is a presumption of truthfulness when a claimant swears to the veracity of their testimony unless there are any reasons to doubt that truthfulness.

[8] In the present claim, I have no reason to doubt any of your testimony. I find that you testified in a straightforward manner here today and provided personal testimony. I also find that your written narrative was detailed and written in a personal manner and that it was consistent with your oral testimony.

[9] You did also submit additional documents to support your claim. These included your identity card, which lists your ethnicity. These documents also included some witness letters as well as screenshots of your social media page, which has some political content. I have no reason to doubt any of these documents, and I find that they all support your allegations as well.

[10] And so, based on your written and oral testimony which I found to be credible, based on the other documents that you submitted, and based on a balance of probabilities, I do accept as fact that you are of the Amhara ethnicity as you claim and that you have been arrested by government forces in 2023 during a protest that you attended.

Nexus to a Convention Ground

[11] A Convention refugee must establish a well-founded fear of persecution because of their race and nationality, their religion, their political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.

[12] I find that what you fear, which you stated was physical harm and detention, constitutes persecution, and I find that that persecution is linked to the Convention ground of ethnicity or race as well as political opinion because of your attendance at the protest where you were detained and because of your political social media posts, and I assessed your claim under section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act of Canada.

[13] Next, I will go over the country condition information to determine whether your fear of future harm has an objective basis. On the general situation in Ethiopia, it is clear from throughout the National Documentation Package and the objective evidence that ethnic violence is present and has been ramping up in the country over the last few years.

[14] For example, at Tab 1.5 of the NDP, the Australian Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade states in a report from 2020 that the security situation in Ethiopia had deteriorated since 2018 and that inter-ethnic clashes had increased significantly at that time. This report stated that inter-ethnic clashes had caused death, and destruction of property, and large-scale internal displacement. Ethiopia recorded the most conflict-related internal displacement in the world in 2018. Ethnic militias had proliferated in the states, and weapons were readily available. That is a bit of an older report. Newer reports confirm the same is going on.

[15] For example, Tab 13.12 of the NDP indicates that in Oromia in 2021, there were reports of various ethnic flare-ups between Amharas and Oromos in the country. Amnesty International reported in that same report that there was — had been a surge of deadly ethnic violence targeting Amharas in various parts of the country. Reports stated that towns that have large populations of Amhara people had been especially volatile, with groups of young Oromo people burning down schools, businesses, and homes of Amhara people.

[16] And then, quite a recent report from 2023 which is at Tab 2.3 of the NDP states that people of Amhara ethnicity were being targeted still in various parts of the country by various armed groups operating in the country.

[17] You, the claimant, also submitted some country condition information, some news articles, found at Exhibit 4.1 of the consolidated list of documents. These news articles indicate that authorities had been cracking down on the Orthodox Tewahedo Church in Ethiopia, with news articles listing several instances of fatal attacks on members of the church as well as the arrest of the church leaders in 2023. I find that these news articles also corroborate your personal experience of being arrested during a protest in 2023.

[18] Lastly, I have also assessed your risk in Ethiopia as a woman. On the risk to women and girls of experiencing gender-based violence, at — Tab 2.1 of the NDP does report that sexual and gender-based violence occurred in all conflict-affected areas of the country. Some organizations reported that conflict-induced displacement had led to increased reports of rape and sexual violence, including sexual slavery and sexual exploitation and abuse.

[19] And so, I find the country condition information is quite clear on the risks you may face. I find that — as I have accepted that you are of the Amhara ethnicity and that you have already been detained during a protest, I find that you face a serious possibility of arrest, and detention, and gender-based violence at the hands of Ethiopian security forces should you return there now, and that is due to your ethnicity, due to your political opinion, as well as due to your gender.

[20] I have assessed whether state protection would be available to you or whether you could relocate safely to a different area within Ethiopia. As it is, the state authority is at least one (1) of the agents of harm in the present claim. I find that there is no state authorities that you can turn to for assistance. As the security situation is volatile throughout the country, I find that there is no area within Ethiopia that you can relocate to currently and remain safely. And so, I find you have neither access to state protection nor an internal fight alternative.

CONCLUSION

[21] And so, for the reasons listed, I find that you meet the definition of a Convention refugee per section 96 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act of Canada, and your claim for protection is therefore accepted. Thank you. That concludes the decision.

 

——— REASONS CONCLUDED ———